A grilled cheese sandwich is famously a quick and easy lunch, but it makes for an even better late-night snack. I’ve experimented with countless bread and cheese combinations, but the soft texture of melted Gruyère and Taleggio combined with sharp mustard and pickles, finished with a crispy cheese veil takes this sandwich to another level. I like to prepare it ahead of time and leave it in my refrigerator so it’s ready to go after a long night. Use a well-seasoned cast-iron pan or a nonstick pan.
2¾-inch-thick slices country bread (sourdough preferred, or Manresa Bread’s levain, if you can get it)
Dijon mustard
1cupgrated Gruyère cheeseplus 1 cup more if making cheese veil
2smalldill picklesthinly sliced
1ounceTaleggioRobiola, or a similar soft, creamy cheese, cut to the size of 2 pats of butter
Instructies
Liberally butter one side of each slice of bread.
This will be the outside.
Flip the bread over and spread a thin layer of Dijon on one half (or both, if you’re a mustard person).
On the other half, layer 1 cup of the Gruyère, the pickles, and the Taleggio.
Push the two halves together with the butter sides facing out to make a sandwich.
Wrap the entire sandwich in plastic wrap and put in your refrigerator with something heavy on top (I use a heavy plate) for 30 minutes, or up to 12 hours, to compress.
When you’re ready to serve, place the sandwich in a medium pan on medium heat.
Place a heavy lid smaller than the pan directly on top of the sandwich.
This will put pressure on the sandwich and the gathering steam will melt the cheese.
Once the bottom of the sandwich has browned, 5 to 7 minutes, use a wide spatula to flip it and place the lid back on top.
When the second side is cooked to golden brown, 5 to 7 minutes more, remove from the pan and set aside.
From here, you can either eat the sandwich or make the cheese veil.
The veil, passed down to me by my business partner Avery Ruzicka, is optional, but well worth the extra time.
Turn the heat to low and spread the remaining 1 cup of Gruyère directly onto the pan, just wide enough to cover the surface of the sandwich.
The cheese will bubble up, melt, and start to turn brown like a pancake.
When the cheese has begun to brown in the middle, set the sandwich in the center.
Use a spatula to scrape the cheese up along the sides of the bread.
Loosen the sandwich from the bottom of the pan, then flip it onto a plate so the cheese veil is on top.